Skip to content There’s a different kind of quiet when you live with someone who’s gone from being a loud little sister to a quiet almost-woman. The old quiet was all mood swings: doors slammed, headphones leaking whatever Spotify decided, the sense of a cyclone trying not to level the house. The new quiet is airless. Like we’re both out of range, or one of us is underwater.
My little sister, Sophia, started it when I got a girlfriend, but I didn’t connect it at first. I thought maybe she was just finally mellowing out. College, hard classes, maybe that one friend group she kept cycling out of. I told myself she was busy, or growing up, or bored with my jokes. The truth was she’d started being quiet around the same time I’d started showing up with someone else’s shampoo on my clothes and someone else’s hair on my pillow.
I didn’t want to believe it was jealousy, but I also started keeping score. Fewer jokes, less eye contact, her leaving the room exactly when my phone lit up. I hated that I noticed, and even more that I started planning around it. Like if I made the kitchen before she woke up I wouldn’t have to see her pulling tea and not talking to me.
This morning she was already there, of course. She looked half-assembled: five-five in bare feet, light brown hair down past her shoulders and stuck a little to her glasses. The glasses were cheap rectangles, fogged from the hot cup she was holding close to her face. Big shirt from the laundry, worn thin, hanging off one collarbone. Sleep shorts that had ridden up so her thighs were mostly bare. Girl-next-door in the worst way: cute before she was anything else. I could see the shape of her mouth over the rim, the start of a frown before she realized I was coming in. Then it vanished, and she did the thing she always did when she wanted to pretend things were fine, which was to look right past me to the window like she was judging the weather.
“Hey,” I said, opening the fridge.
“Hey,” Sophia said. I could hear the word getting typed out, not spoken.
She poured sugar. I got milk. She wiped the counter, even though she hadn’t spilled. I did the Cheerios. She started a second cup of tea she didn’t need. It was all just frictionless.
Then my phone vibrated and I felt her go still, like, the act of texting in the room was enough to put her on mute. I read the text without replying and shut the phone off. When I looked up, she was on the balcony, not moving, just staring at the street. She’d left her cup on the table, and a ring of wet ceramic was already seeping into the wood.
Sophia had always liked that balcony. It was barely four feet wide and the outdoor furniture was a crime against taste, but she sat there like it was the last high ground left in the world. When we were kids I used to think she could fly if she wanted, she just didn’t want to embarrass the rest of us by leaving.
I took the phone and the cup and followed her out, mostly because I was sick of trying not to notice her moods. If she wanted to stare at the world, she could do it with a brother in the chair next to her. The air outside was hot already, the glass rail humming with sun, but Sophia curled up like she was still cold.
I set her cup in front of her and leaned on the rail. “You want to talk about it?” I said.
She made a noise I recognized as a preface to nothing.
“Come on,” I said, “I’m not a mind reader.”
She looked at me for a second, just long enough that I could see the actual shape of her eyes through the glasses, then away. “I feel left behind,” she said. “That’s all.”
“Left behind by what?”
She picked at the side of her thumb. “Everyone has somebody,” she said. “And now you do too.”
I was supposed to laugh, or tell her she was being dramatic, or do the thing I’d done my whole life where I said “you’re fine.” But something in the way she said it was all wrong.
I shrugged, trying to sound normal. “You’re eighteen. You’ve got time.”
She smiled, but it didn’t reach the top half of her face. “I’m the last one, Chad. Out of all my friends. They talk about it like it’s …” She stopped. “Like it’s a ride at the amusement park and I’m the only one too short to get on.”
It took a second to realize what she meant. Then it was impossible to unhear.
She saw me get it. She said, “I didn’t mean—”
“No, I know what you meant.” I sat down in the other chair and let the sun do its thing to my neck. “I just didn’t realize it was… I don’t know. A thing.”
“It’s not,” she said, lying. Then she looked right at me, like she was daring me to contradict her. “You’re the only one who ever acted like it wasn’t a big deal.”
I had to say something. “It’s not a big deal.”
She nodded, but the smile was gone. I tried to find the right joke to fix it, but the list was empty. The girl who used to kill me with a well-timed roast, sitting here wishing she was like everybody else. It felt backwards.
I said, “You know there’s nothing wrong with—”
“Being a loser?” she said.
“Not having a body count. Jesus, Sophia.”
She rolled her eyes. “That’s not what it’s about. It’s just …” She pressed her fingers to her lips, trying to choose the right word. “It’s like waiting for something to start, and everyone else is already halfway through.”
I said, “You’ll meet someone. You’re, like, disgustingly smart and not hideous.”
She huffed, a sound that used to mean “thanks, asshole,” but now it meant something softer. “I just don’t want it to be some guy who …” She trailed off.
There was a long pause where I could hear the lawn guys on the street and the sound of a plane overhead. Then she looked at me with this weird, searching look, like she was trying to figure out how to say something she wasn’t supposed to say.
“Don’t freak out,” she said, “but can I ask you a favor?”
That was never a good setup.
I braced for it. “Shoot.”
She exhaled. “I want you to do it. Just once, so it’s over.”
The first thing my brain did was try to translate it into something normal, like a code. Tutor her in calculus. Take her to a party so she’s not awkward. Even after she said it, my mind kept running the other options.
Then she just watched me, eyes big behind the glasses, and I knew she meant exactly what she’d said.
I laughed, because I had to. “You want me to—”
She nodded.
“That’s crazy,” I said.
She nodded again, but she didn’t look away. “Is it?”
“It’s literally …” I stopped, because “illegal” was bullshit, and “gross” was a word that belonged to other people, not to her, not to the girl who still wore my old hoodies and used my Spotify family plan.
“It’s not that big a deal,” she said quietly.
I felt the air go out of me. “Sophia.”
She shrugged. “You always said if I ever needed anything I should ask.”
“That’s not what I meant and you know it.”
She smiled. “Maybe I’m taking advantage of a loophole.”
I was supposed to say no. I tried to. I opened my mouth to shoot her down, but she already looked like she’d survived the worst of it. The part where I said no was just paperwork.
“Don’t you want it to be …” I trailed off, because I couldn’t say “special” or “romantic” without wanting to die.
She finished it for me. “With someone who doesn’t care if I cry or fuck up or don’t like it? Someone who’s not going to post about it or turn it into a story for his friends?”
“That’s what you think happens?”
“I’ve seen the group chats, Chad. I know what happens.”
I tried again, quieter. “I have a girlfriend.”
She shrugged. “You don’t have to tell her.”
I tried to feel horror at how casual she was about it, but it wasn’t horror. It was relief that she could even talk to me this way. That she didn’t see me as dangerous, or gross, or anything but safe.
“That’s not how this works,” I said.
She didn’t answer. She just looked at her hands for a long time.
I wanted to touch her, to comfort her, but anything I did was going to be the wrong thing. I settled for, “You don’t have to prove anything to anybody.”
She said, “I want to do this. Not for them. For me.” She looked at me then, all the way in, and I knew she wasn’t going to let me joke my way out of it. “Please. I trust you.”
I said, “You know if you tell me to stop I’ll stop, right?”
She nodded.
“I mean it. You say stop, and it’s done. Nothing weird after.”
She gave me a small smile. “Okay.”
I looked at the sliding door. “Now?”
She stood up. “Now.”
I followed her inside, up the stairs, down the old hallway we’d grown up in. The sun through the bathroom window was turning everything gold, and I could see the dust motes in the air, moving in the wake of her. She opened her door without looking back. I hesitated, just a second, then went in after her.
Sophia’s room hadn’t changed in a while, except there was no more wall of concert posters and the bedding was just a plain white comforter now. Her laptop was on the nightstand, pink case, open to a study playlist. She turned it off, then sat at the edge of the bed, like she didn’t know what she was supposed to do next.
I sat next to her. We both stared at the wall in front of us. She took her glasses off and put them on the nightstand. She turned to me, face red, but her hands were steady.
“You don’t have to be gentle,” she said, “but I’d like it if you were.”
I said, “I can do gentle.”
She waited. I got the hint.
I reached for her hand and she let me take it. Her fingers were cool, but not cold. She held on tight, which surprised me.
I leaned in. Her lips were soft, no chapstick, no flavor. She let me kiss her, eyes closed, breathing hard. Then she kissed me back, and I could feel her shaking a little, but it wasn’t fear. It was that adrenaline you get when you’re about to jump.
I put my arm around her, the way I’d done a thousand times in the past, but now it meant something. She melted into it. I felt her relax, all at once, like she’d been holding her breath since the day I got a girlfriend and only now let it out.
I kissed her again, with tongue this time. She responded right away, and I felt her hand touch my jaw, then my shoulder. She was so soft everywhere, it felt unreal.
“You sure?” I said, one more time.
She nodded. “Please.”
I let my hand drift down her back, palm open, warm through the thin cotton of her shirt. She pressed in closer. I could feel her chest against me, the small rapid heart under her ribs.
She guided my hand under her shirt, over her stomach. Her skin was so smooth it barely registered as touch. She kept her eyes closed, but her mouth was open now, lips parted. I slid my hand up, and she arched her back, letting me find the edge of her bralette.
I cupped her breast, not hard, not casual. She made a sound like a whimper, but kept her face turned up for me. I kissed her again, lighter this time. She kissed back, hard enough to surprise me.
I pulled back a little, so I could look at her.
“You’re beautiful.”
She made a face, but I could see her eyes water. “Liar,” she said.
“I’m not.”
She pulled her shirt off. Just like that. It was sudden, and awkward, and her hair got stuck and she had to yank it free. She looked like she wanted to laugh and die at the same time.
Her bralette was pale, nothing fancy, and she was smaller up top than I remembered. The glasses off made her look even younger.
I reached behind her, found the clasp, and hesitated. “Okay?”
She nodded.
I undid it. She let it slide off. She covered them with her arms, then slowly moved her hands away.
“You’re gorgeous,” I said. I meant it.
She took off her sleep shorts herself. No underwear. She looked away when she did it, like the world was ending, but she didn’t stop.
She was just Sophia with nothing left to hide behind. Pale all over except that faint gold on her shoulders and calves. Soft waist, real hips. When she turned to get the shorts off her ankle I saw the rest of it: unmarked, rounded, ordinary-pretty, the kind of ass that doesn’t look like it belongs in a sentence with her name. A couple of freckles on her shoulders. One on the upper curve of her left breast.
She sat back on the edge of the bed. Small-to-medium breasts, sloped, nipples light pink and tight, the left one a little darker. Soft patch of brown above, trimmed, not gone. Pinker between her legs than the rest of her. Thighs pale and the faintest bit dimpled. Stomach not flat unless she sucked it in. She did, just for a second, then let it out. I looked. I couldn’t not look. I tried to be clinical. It didn’t work.
She was breathing fast.
“You want to get under the blanket?” I said, thinking it’d make her feel less on display.
She nodded.
We got under the comforter. She pressed into my side, her bare legs against my sweats, the shirtless line of her cold at first. I’d never been this close to someone I loved and also knew every embarrassing thing about.
She touched my chest, then my abs, then went for the waistband of my sweats. I helped. I left my boxers on until she gave me a look.
“I want to see,” she said.
I shrugged and slipped them down. She took a long look, eyes wide, no poker face.
I said, “It’s not going to be huge, if that’s what you’re wondering.”
She bit her lip. “I was wondering if it would look scary.”
I laughed. “It’s not scary. Promise.”
She reached out and touched me, not like in porn, more like she was poking an animal she thought might bite. Her hand was shaking, but she wrapped it around the shaft, squeezed a little, then let go.
She said, “I don’t know what to do.”
“Nothing you don’t want.”
She kissed me again, harder. Then she lay back, glasses still off, hair fanned on the pillow. “Tell me what to do,” she said.
I got on top of her, careful. She was looking straight at the ceiling, face tense. I touched her thighs, then ran a finger up the inside. She was shaking, so I went slow. When I touched her, she jerked a little, but not away.
“You’re wet,” I said. “That’s good.”
She made a little noise.
I used my fingers, slow, gentle, just like I’d do with anyone else’s first time. She spread her legs a little wider. I found her clit and rubbed soft circles. She gasped, but then went really still, letting me keep going.
After a minute she said, “I think I’m ready.”
I lined up, but hovered, not pushing in. “Breathe,” I said.
She did.
I went in, slow as I could. She tensed, but didn’t pull away. The first inch was tight as hell. I stopped, let her get used to it. She let out a shaky breath. “You okay?”
She nodded. “Keep going.”
I went another inch, then another. She gripped my forearm hard. Her nails dug in, but I didn’t care. She was so tight I could barely move.
“It’s going to hurt a little,” I said.
“I know,” she said, “just do it.”
I pushed in all the way. She whimpered, then bit her lip so hard I thought it would bleed.
I didn’t thrust at first. I just held her, kissed her cheek, ran my hand down her hair.
She whispered, “It’s not that bad.”
I started to fuck my sister, barely, back and forth, just enough that I could feel every ridge of her, the way she clenched when I bottomed out and then forgot to unclench. She was hot inside in a way that made the “favor” story sound stupid even in my own head. She was horny and badly wanted to get fucked. I kept my weight on my elbows so I wouldn’t crush her.
She nodded against my mouth. “Don’t stop. Just—slow.”
I gave her my cock slow. Every pull dragged; every push made her breath hitch like she was counting. I kissed the corner of her eye where it was wet and told myself that was comfort, not hunger. My hips disagreed. I could feel how easy it would be to forget she had never done this and just take the rest of the afternoon.
She hooked a calf over the back of my thigh, clumsy, like she’d seen it somewhere and was trying it on. The angle changed. I slid deeper without meaning to and she made a sound that was half pain, half something I was not supposed to hear from her.
“Sorry—”
“No. That, do that.”
I did that. Shorter strokes, still careful, the wet sound of it starting to fill the room. She was getting slicker around me. The tight ring at the start of her had given up a little. I could move. I hated how good that felt, fucking my sister.
“You can go harder,” she whispered. “I’m not going to break.”
I went harder. The mattress complained. Her small breasts jiggled under me; I ducked my head and took a nipple in my mouth because looking at her face while I did this was worse. She arched, fingers in my hair, and said my name like she wasn’t sure she was allowed to use it in this context.
I reached between us and found her clit with my thumb. She jumped, then pushed up into my hand and my cock at the same time, chasing it. The shy version of her was still there, the girl from the balcony, the fogged glasses, the tea she didn’t need, but her body had stopped asking permission.
“Chad … wait … I think …”
She came quietly. Her mouth open on my shoulder, inner muscles fluttering around me in little helpless pulls. I had to freeze or I was going to follow her immediately. I held still inside my sister while she shook through it, and the good-deed story finally died. I wasn’t doing her a favor. I was fucking her. I was going to finish in her.
“I’m close,” I said. It came out wrecked. “I don’t have anything. I should pull out.”
Her legs locked at my back.
“Don’t,” she said. “Just … inside. Please. I want it over. I want all of it.”
That should have been the moment I became a better person. I thrust instead. Deeper, messier, the last of the gentleness burned off. She took it, eyes wet, watching me like she needed to see the exact second I stopped pretending. I buried myself to the base and came in her raw, pulsing so hard my vision narrowed, spilling into the tight heat of a forbidden pussy. I kept grinding through it, emptying everything I had told myself I wouldn’t give her.
I stayed in her until it stopped. Then I stayed a second longer because pulling out felt like admitting what we’d done. When I finally did, it was slow. She hissed. I looked down without meaning to: her pink, used, a slick line of me already leaking onto the white comforter between her thighs.
She was breathing like she’d run. She reached for her glasses, missed, and left them. Her hand found my wrist instead.
“That wasn’t nothing,” she said.
I lay down beside her, still half on her pillow, and stared at the ceiling the way she had when I’d first gotten on top of her.
After a long time, she said, “I’m not left behind anymore.”
I laughed, because what else could I do?
She put her head on my chest and closed her eyes.
The room was quieter than it had ever been, and it was fine. It was more than fine.
Enjoyed this story?
Browse the books → Incest Books
Get 50% off your first order.
Use code: FIRSTREAD
Or if you want to read similar stories → Brother sister incest stories